TRAIL SMELTER CASE
PARTIES: United States of America, Canada.
SPECIAL AGREEMENT: Convention of Ottawa, April 15, 1935.
ARBITRATORS: Charles Warren (U.S.A.), Robert A. E. Greenshields (Canada), Jan Frans Hostie (Belgium).
AWARD: April 15, 1938, and March 11, 1941.
There is no doubt that in the present case, there is resjudicata. The three traditional elements for identiﬁcation: parties, object and cause (Permanent Court of International Justice, Judgment 11, Series A, No. 13, Dissenting Opinion by M. Anzilotti, p. 23) are the same. ( Cf. Permanent Court of International Justice, Series B, No. 11, p. 30.)